Imagine this Northern Michigan girls: You might have stood in an ice cream cone line behind American Idol contestant and heartthrob Sam Woolf. Maybe you spread your towel next to him on a Northern Michigan beach. Perhaps you heard him perform at a Harbor Springs summer festival … Who knows? According to the Petoskey News Review, the Michigan native who now lives in Florida has been a summer resident of the Charlevoix area most of his life.

Whether you’ve brushed shoulders with him or not, you can tell American Idol judges Harry Connick Jr., Jennifer Lopez and Keith Urban that Sam—one of 12 finalists—should be the next AMERICAN IDOL. Click to cast your vote, then watch tonight’s conclusion of season XIII on Fox.