On a particularly verdant stretch of the storied Au Sable River near Grayling, John and Jane Haggerty look out the windows of their vintage log home and feel right with the world. Cozy. Warm. Comfortable.

Their sense of calm is no doubt enhanced by the 1930’s embrace of the home. But fact is, some of the place is brand new. And visitors would be hard pressed to discern where the original ends and the new begins, because the addition’s finish work, decor and scale are so authentic. Part of a compound on the Au Sable’s South Branch that included a main lodge and several outbuildings, this formerly rundown guesthouse has all the modern conveniences yet retains the original outdoorsman-getaway feel. It’s rustic yet aristocratic, in the spirit of automotive moguls like General Motors Chairman W. C. Durant and George W. Mason, president of Kelvinator-Nash, both of whom built hunting and fishing lodges along the rambling river banks nearby.

The Haggertys bought the property in 2001 and immediately went to work on the exterior problems, replacing all of the windows and woodpecker-ravaged logs, redoing the crumbled chinking and shoring up the bridges that conveyed them back and forth across the river. They also brought their friend who worked on their home in Birmingham, interior designer Julia Knevels, up to Grayling to see the place. She and architect Kevin Hart teamed up to transform this oddly arranged gem of a cabin into something more functional and spacious.

“It was impractical,” says Knevels, who was the point person on the project. The kitchen was downstairs, the living room, small den and bedroom were on the top with a narrow, curved staircase in between and another on the outside. And there was only one small bathroom. “Everything was so tight and so steep,” she recalls. “But the house had very good bones—it wasn’t cheaply built.”

Hart agreed. When he brought his team up to see the cabin, he said it looked “almost fake, like a painting, it was so peaceful and serene. We didn’t want to leave.” Knevels and Hart launched the project with the goal of keeping a minimal contrast between old and new. The result was a new addition behind the original house that includes an open, light-filled kitchen, pantry, two guest rooms and a bath. On the outside, the stick-built addition is faced with three-quarter logs to match the original structure. On the inside, the team installed built-ins galore, a Knevels trademark. To combat the darkness inherent in log homes, overhead spotlights, table and countertop lamps and corner lights ooze warmth.

Those old tight steps were replaced, too, by a comfortably wide staircase. The Haggertys gave the cabin-sized kitchen downstairs a sprucing up and use it for extra storage. They also left the original upstairs living room virtually unchanged. Built to frame the rolling, sun-dappled Au Sable, it’s hands down the best nature show around.

Home Resources

Julia Knevels, Birmingham, 248-540-7412

Kevin Hart, AIA, Birmingham, 248-642-9427

Don Kernstock, Grayling, 989-348-8945
Mike Graham, Grayling, 989-348-7195

Kitchen Cabinetry
Premier Custom-Built Inc, 717-354-3059

Kitchen Appliances
Witbeck Appliance, 877-948-2325

Brunschwig & Fils
Clarence House

Click the cover to read the latest issue of Northern Home & Cottage magazine.

[publication mode=”thumb” name=”nhc” align=”center” link=”viewnow”]

Northern Homes & Cottages

Photo(s) by Jeff Garland Photography